Sep 1, 2013 | coins, education, medals, tokens
One of the benefits of living in the Washington, DC area is the access to the great museums. Even better, most of them are free or charge a convenience fee to register for entry times online. A few weeks ago, I was able to take advantage of this when my nephew and nice brought their parents, my brother and sister-in-law, to the area in order to visit a few of the museums in the area.
After a late breakfast, we went to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. Aside from its mission to memorialize and teach the lessons of the atrocities during World War II it strives to educate people as to their responsibilities in the face of hatred and genocide while promoting human dignity. The museum is celebrating 20 years having been dedicated on April 22, 1993 and opening to the public on April 26, 1993. You can read more about the history of the museum here.
If you come to visit the Washington, D.C. area, I highly recommend that you allocate at least four hours to go through the museum. If you are like me and like to read everything, view all of the exhibits and displays, and watch all of the videos then you should consider scheduling more time.
What does the Holocaust have to do with numismatics? First, in some of the displays are scrip and coupons used mainly in Jewish ghettos for rationing of goods and services. It shows how an economy attempted to survive in the harshest of circumstances. While some of the scrip are reproductions, it gives the museum goer a sense of what those in the ghetto might have gone through.
Another group that created their own script were the Roma (Gypsies). Although the Roma were Aryan, they were persecuted as being inferior to the Germans. However, when they were rounded up and brought to the concentration camps, the Gypsies created their own order along with the other non-Jewish population as they were segregated in the camps.
There is not a lot of money-related artifacts, especially for the period following the start of World War II, but what is there shows its importance as part of the survival of the persecuted. The power of money was on display the movie Schindler’s List where Jewish artists were forced to create printing plates in order to counterfeit British money. In fact, the movie The Counterfeiters is about the counterfeit operation set up by Nazis to weaken the economies of the enemies.
Before leaving the museum requires a stop in the gift shop. Amongst the books and other items to help you remember your visit are the official medal and some smaller tokens. The medal is made of bronze and is about the size of a United States half-dollar (30 mm). The medal appears to be in a ringed holder that is embedded in a card. Two smaller tokens includes one that reads “What You Do Matters” and one with an image of a candle cut out from the metal with the words “Remember” across the top and “Never Again” on the bottom. Both tokens are 20 mm in diameter.
-
-
Obverse of the US Holocaust Memorial Museum Medal
-
-
Reverse of the US Holocaust Memorial Museum Medal
-
-
“What you do matters” refers to how you react in the face of genocide where ever it occurs matters.
-
-
“Always Remember” token with cutout of a candle.
Collecting coins, tokens, and medals of the places you visit is one way to enhance your collection. To complete the collection from this visit I also purchased three postcards. The postcards, medal, and tokens were placed in a page that holds three 4×6 items with two postcards in one pocket, the medal in its own pocket, and the tokens in the pocket with the single card. The page is in a binder with a note describing when I obtained these items, who I was with, and some other thoughts. Adding the note personalizes the collection and will remind me of the visit many years from now.
Jul 30, 2012 | BEP, coins, currency, education, legislative, policy, US Mint
There has been a lot of legislation passed by Congress that affects the coin and currency production in the United States. While some of it has been as mundane as changing the composition of coins or the approval of a commemorative coin, there are some that has had a significant impact on coin and currency production. Here is a list of those laws that had a major impact.
- Coinage Act of 1792
- The first coin-related law passed by congress and signed by President George Washington on April 2, 1792, establishes a mint, says that congress is the regulating authority of coins, and establishes the dollar as the unit of money. It made the United States one of the first countries to use a decimal system for currency and established legal tender laws. It is the foundation for the creation of the money production in the United States.
- Act of April 10, 1806
- This act regulates the legal tender value of foreign coins used in the United States.
- Act of April 21, 1806
- This act establishes the penalty for counterfeiting coins to be between three and five years of hard labor. Although there was no law regarding counterfeiting coins before this act, it was assumed that penalty was death because of the statements printed on colonial currency.
- Coinage Act of 1834
- This act changed the ratio of silver-to-gold weight from 15:1 that was established in the Coinage Act of 1792 to 16:1, setting the price of an ounce of gold to $20.67. This was done to strengthen the financial system after the Panic of 1833 and stem the tide of paper currency in favor of “hard money.” President Andrew Jackson signed this bill into law on June 27, 1834.
- Coinage Act of 1849
- Signed into law by President James K. Polk as one of his last acts as president on March 3, 1849, it established the use of gold for a $1 coin and the $20 gold double eagle coin. This act also refined the variances that were permissible for United States gold coinage. This act came largely because of the California Gold Rush.
- Coinage Act of 1857
- Signed into law by President Franklin Pierce February 21, 1857, this act repealed the legal tender status for foreign coins in the United States. It required the Treasury to exchange foreign coins at a market rate set by Treasury. This act discontinued the half-cent and reduced the size of the one-cent coin from 27mm (large cent) to the modern size of 19.05mm (small cent) that is still being used today.
- National Bank Act of 1863
- Originally known as the National Currency Act and signed into law by President Abraham Lincoln on February 25, 1863, it created a single currency standard for the United States where the notes would be backed by the United States Treasury and printed by the federal government. The result of this act lead to the establishment of the National Currency Bureau which was later rename to the Bureau of Engraving and Printing.
- Coinage Act of 1864
- This act changed the composition of the one-cent coin to bronze (0.95 copper, 0.05 tin and zinc) from 0.88 copper and 0.12 nickel. It authorized the minting of the two-cent coins with the motto “In God We Trust” to appear the first time on a United States coin. President Abraham Lincoln signed this act into law on April 22, 1864.
- Coinage Act of 1873
- Sometimes referred to as the “Crime of ’73,” demonetized silver and set the standard for gold as the backing of the national currency. This act placed the U.S. Mint under the jurisdiction of the Department of the Treasury and officially established four branch mints at Philadelphia, San Francisco, Carson City, and Denver. Two assay offices were established in New York and Boise City, Idaho. The act also ended the production of the half-dime, silver three-cent piece, and two-cent coin. President Ulysses S. Grant signed this act on February 12, 1873.
- Bland-Allison Act
- Named for Rep. Richard P Bland (D-MO) and Sen. William B. Allison (R-IA), the act required the Treasury Department to buy silver from western mines and put them into circulation as silver dollars. The act authorized the striking of the Morgan Dollar. President Rutherford B. Hayes vetoed the bill but congress overrode his veto on February 28, 1873.
- Sherman Silver Purchase Act
- Signed into law by President Benjamin Harrison on July 14, 1890 and named for Sen. John Sherman (R-OH), the law increased the amount of silver the government was required to purchase from western silver mines.
- Federal Reserve Act of 1913
- President Woodrow Wilson signed the Federal Reserve Act into law on December 23, 1913 that allowed the creation of the Federal Reserve System as the central bank of the United States. It also granted the Federal Reserve authority to issue Federal Reserve Notes and Federal Reserve Banknotes.
- Pittman Act
- Named for Sen. Key Pittman (D-NV) and signed into law by President Woodrow Wilson on April 23, 1918 authorized the conversion of up to 350 million silver dollars into bullion for sale or to be used to strike subsidiary coinage. The act required the government to buy all silver mined in the United States at a fixed price of $1 per ounce above market rate.
- Gold Reserve Act of 1934
- Even though Franklin D. Roosevelt as part of Executive Order 6102 ordered the withdrawal of gold from the economy on April 5, 1933, there was one challenge and one reissue of the executive order. Congress felt that the executive order needed codification and passed this act on January 30, 1934. Roosevelt signed the law the same day. The law withdrew all gold and gold certificates from circulation and outlawed most private possession of gold with the exception of some jewelry and collector coins. This act established the nominal price of gold to $35 per troy ounce.
- Public Law 84-851 (70 Stat. 732, H.J.Res. 396)
- On July 30, 1956, this law established the national motto of the United States to be “In God We Trust.” While the motto appeared on most coins of the time, the Bureau of Engraving and Printing phased it in on currency between 1957 and 1965.
- Coinage Act of 1965
- In response to the coin shortages caused by the rising silver prices, the act eliminated silver from circulating dimes, and quarters while reducing the amount of silver used to strike half-dollars from 90-percent to 40-percent for five years. After five years, the half-dollar would be struck using the same copper-nickel clad composition as the lower denominations. The act forbade the striking of silver dollars for five year ending an experiment with the striking of Peace Dollars in 1964. Finally, the act made all coins and currency produced in the United States and certain bank issues as legal tender–which reversed the 1876 demonetization of the Trade Dollar. Signed into law on July 23, 1965 by President Lyndon B. Johnson, it is seen as the dividing line between “classic” and “modern” coinage.
- Hobby Protection Act or 1973
- Signed into law by President Richard Nixon on November 29, 1973, this act requires that replica collectibles, including coins, be marked “plainly and permanently” with the word “COPY” to indicate that the item is not genuine. This act grants the Federal Trade Commission permission to take action against suppliers who violate this act.
- Statue of Liberty-Ellis Island Commemorative Coin Act—Title II: Liberty Coins
- Signed by President Ronald Reagan on July 9, 1985, Title II of this act allowed for the U.S. Mint to establish the American Eagle Silver Bullion Program.
- Gold Bullion Coin Act of 1985
- A few months after the passage of the act to allow for silver bullion coins, this act was enacted on December 17, 1985 that lead to the establishment of the American Eagle Gold Bullion Program.
- 50 States Commemorative Coin Program Act
- Considered one of the most significant act affecting circulating coinage since the Coinage Act of 1965, this act lead to the very successful 50 State Quarters Program. Section 4 of the act, named the “United States $1 Coin Act of 1997” changed the composition of the one dollar coin to be “golden in color” which lead to the creation of the Sacagawea “Golden” Dollar. President Bill Clinton signed this bill into law on December 1, 1997.
Jul 13, 2012 | coins, education, history, US Mint
A mintmark is part of the coin design that tells which mint the coins were produced. Using mintmarks to identify where coins were made began in ancient Greece. Coins that were released into circulation were required to have a “Magistrate Mark,” a distinct mark representing the magistrate in charge of producing the coin. If a coin was to have problems, whether by accident or on purpose, the government knows who the responsible party was.
Mintmarks were first used in ancient times as a quality control mechanism. If a coin did not fit the specifications (under or overweight, not the right metal, etc.) it was easy to identify where the coin was made.
Another type of mark made on non-United State coin is a privy mark. A privy mark is a small design added to the coin to identify the where the coin was made, the coiner responsible for the coin, or some other aspect of the coin’s production for quality control purposes. Privy marks fell out of favor in modern times and countries with multiple branches use lettered mintmarks. Some mints use privy marks to differentiate different types of non-circulating legal tender coins.
Mintmarks used on United States coins are as follows:
P: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (1793-present)
The U.S. Mint was formally founded with the passage of the Mint Act of 1792. David Rittenhouse, the first Mint Director, was able to find a building in Philadelphia and begin operations in 1793. The first mint building served the country until 1833. The second mint building served from 1833-1901 and was demolished in 1902. The third mint was in service from 1901-1969. The building is now part of the Community College of Philadelphia. The fourth mint, located two blocks from the location of the first mint building, was opened in 1969 and continues to be used today. Up until 2009, it was the largest mint building in the world. However, no other mint in the world produces more circulating coinage than the Philadelphia mint.
All coins struck in Philadelphia from the founding of the Mint in 1793 until 1980 did not include a mintmark. The exception was the Type 2 Jefferson Nickels minted using the wartime alloy from 1942-1945. Coins struck using the silver-copper-manganese alloy feature a large mintmark above Monticello, including a “P” for Philadelphia.
In 1979, Susan B. Anthony dollars struck in Philadelphia included the “P” mintmark.
Beginning in 1980, all coins struck in Philadelphia, except for the Lincoln Cent, includes the “P” mintmark.
C: Charlotte, North Carolina (1838-1861)
Charlotte became the first branch mint outside of Philadelphia. Authorized in 1835 following the gold strike at the Reed Gold Mine, it first became operational in 1838. The Charlotte branch mint was closed when the building was seized by the Confederacy during the Civil War in 1861. It was not reopened after the war. The Charlotte Mint’s “C” mintmark only appears on gold coins.
D: Dahlonega, Georgia (1838-1861)
The Dahlonega Branch Mint was authorized by congress in 1837 after the Georgia Gold Strike. It opened for production in 1838. Like the Charlotte Mint, the Dahlonega Mint was seized by the Confederacy during the Civil War in 1861 and was never reopened. Gold coins dated 1838-1861 with the “D” mintmark were struck in Dahlonega. Coins with the “D” mintmark starting in 1906 were struck in Denver.
O: New Orleans, Louisiana (1838-1861 and 1879-1909)
The branch mint at New Orleans was authorized by congress in 1836 as part of a discussion to make New Orleans a central trading gateway to the Midwest. This branch mint struck all denominations with the “O” mintmark. In 1861, the building was seized by the Confederacy and used by the Confederate government to strike coins. The Union Army recaptured New Orleans and the building in 1862. Unlike Charlotte and Dahlonega, the New Orleans Mint was eventually reopened. Its second life began as an assay office in 1876. With the passage of the Bland-Allison Silver Act of 1878, the building was refurbished to bring it back to coining standard and was used to strike silver coins, mostly dollars, until 1909. It was closed for the last time in 1909 with production down and Denver taking over the production load.
S: San Francisco, California (1854-1955 and 1968-present)
The San Francisco branch mint was opened in 1854 to assay and coin gold discovered during the California Gold Rush. The first building, known as the “Granite Lady,” was one of the few buildings to survive the Great San Francisco Earthquake of 1906. During the aftermath of the earthquake, Superintendant Frank Leach helped local residents by allowing them to use the grounds as a refuge. A new building was opened in 1937 and celebrated its 75th anniversary in 2012. Today, the Granite Lady is being refurbished as the Museum of San Francisco.
San Francisco produced circulating coins with the “S” mintmark until 1955 when production was suspended and the facility was “downgraded” to an assay office. Production of proof coinage was transferred to San Francisco in 1968 and they began to strike some coinage for circulation until 1974. Since 1975, San Francisco produced only proof coins along with cents without mintmarks to supplement production from Philadelphia. It is not possible to distinguish from no mintmark cents from either mint. San Francisco also produced circulating Susan B. Anthony dollars 1979-1981 with the “S” mintmark. They were granted mint status in 1988.
CC: Carson City, Nevada (1870-1893)
After the major discovery of silver as part of the Comstock Lode in what is Virginia City today, politicians lobbied congress for the formation of a branch mint to assay and strike coins. Congress authorized a mint in 1868 for nearby Carson City and the building was opened for production in 1870. The Carson City branch mint struck silver and gold coins but in lesser amounts than the other mints, making their coins highly collectible and more expensive because of their rarity. The “CC” mintmark is the only two-character mintmark used on U.S. coins.
Production ended in 1893 with the reduced production from nearby silver mines. Starting in 1895 the building served as an Assay Office until the gold recall of 1933. The building was sold to the State of Nevada in 1939 and was turned into the Nevada State Museum.
D: Denver, Colorado (1906-present)
During the Pikes Peak Gold Rush, congress authorized the opening of a Denver assay office in 1863. Congress authorized the building of a branch mint in 1896 and construction began in 1898. Operations from the assay office were transferred to the new building in 1904 and the mint started to strike circulation coins in 1906. Denver struck gold coins until 1933 when gold was recalled. All coins with the “D” mintmark struck since 1906 were minted in Denver. Earlier gold coins dated 1838-1861 were struck in Dahlonega, Georgia.
W: West Point, New York (1976-present)
In 1937, the Treasury built a facility on the northern part of the campus of the U.S. Military Academy to store silver. Originally, it was called the West Point Bullion Repository and was nicknamed as “The Fort Knox of Silver.” From 1968-1973, West Point produced cents without a mintmark in order to supplement the production from Philadelphia. They also produced Bicentennial and Washington Quarters 1975-1979 without mintmarks.
The “W” mintmark first appeared on the 1983 Olympics Commemorative Coins. West Point produces coins for the American Eagle Bullion program without mintmarks but produces collectable versions of the American Eagle with the “W” mintmark. Other commemoratives have been struck at West Point that includes the “W” mintmark.
The same bill that returned the San Francisco branch mint back to mint status in 1983 granted mint status to the West Point branch mint.
M: Manila, Philippines (1920-1941)
After the Philippines became a colony of the United States, the U.S. Mint established a branch mint in Manila. It is the only branch mint outside of the continental United States. The mint opened in 1920 and produced coins in one, five, ten, twenty, and fifty centavo denominations. Coins struck by this mint bear either the “M” mintmark or no mintmark.
Jul 2, 2012 | currency, education, exonumia, medals, tokens
Although the dominant area of numismatics is the collection and study of legal tender coins, numismatics is more than just coins. Numismatic is the collecting and study of items used in the exchange for goods, resolve debts, and objects used to represent something of monetary value. This opens up numismatic collecting to a wide range of items and topics that could make “the hunt” to put together the collection as much fun as having the collection.
Exonumia
Exonumia is the study and collection of tokens, medals, or other coin-like objects that are not considered legal tender. Exonumia opens numismatics to a wide variety of topics that could not be satisfied by collecting coins alone. An example of exonumia is the collection of transportation tokens. You may be familiar with transportation tokens from your local bus or subway company who used to sell tokens to place into fare boxes. Others may have used tokens to more easily pay in the express lanes at bridges and tunnels. A person who collects transportation tokens is called a Vecturist. For more information on being a Vecturist, visit the website for the American Vecturist Association.
Token collecting can be the ultimate local numismatic collection. Aside from transportation tokens, some states and localities issued tax tokens in order to collect fractions of a cent in sales taxes to allow those trying to get by in during down economic times to stretch their money further. Some communities issued trade tokens that allowed those who used them to use them as cash at selected merchants. Some merchants issued trade tokens that were an early form of coupons that were traded as coupons are traded today.
While tokens are items used to represent monetary value, medals are used to honor, commemorate, or advertize. The U.S. Mint produces medals that honor people, presidents, and events. Medals produced by the U.S. Mint are those authorized by law as a national commemoration including the medal remembering the attacks of 9/11.
Commemorative medals are not limited to those produced by the U.S. Mint. State and local governments have also authorized the producing medals on their behalf that were produced by private mints. Many organizations also have created medals honoring members or people that have influenced the organization. Companies have produced medals to honor their place in the community or something about the company and their community.
Many medals have designs that can be more beautiful than on coins since they are not limited to governmental mandated details and their smaller production runs allows for more details to be added. Medals can be larger and thicker than coins and made in a higher relief than something that could be manufactured by a government mint.
Exonumia collecting also involves elongated and encased coins. You may have seen the machines in many areas where you pay 50-cents, give it one of your cents, turn the wheel and the cent comes out elongated with a pattern pressed into the coin. Elongated coins have been used as advertisements, calling cards, and as a souvenir.
Encased coins are coin encircled with a ring that has mostly been used as an advertisement. One side will call the coin a lucky coin or provide sage advice with the other side advertising a business. Another form of encased coins are encased stamps. Encased stamps were popular in the second half of the 19th century and used for trade during times when there were coin shortages.
Other exonumia includes badges, counter stamped coins, wooden money, credit cards, and casino tokens. Counter stamped coins are coins that have been circulated in foreign markets that were used in payment for goods. When the coin was accepted in the foreign market, the merchant would examine the coin and impress a counter stamp on the coin proclaiming the coin to be genuine based on their examination. Although coins were counter stamped in many areas of the world, it was prevalent in China where the coins were stamped with the Chinese characters representing the person who examined the coin. These Chinese symbols are commonly referred to as “chop marks.”
One type of counter stamped coins are stickered coins. Stickered coins were popular in the first half of the 20th century; they were used as an advertisement. Merchants would purchase stickers and apply them to their change so that as the coins circulated, the advertising would reach more people. Some stickered coins acted as a coupon to entice the holder to bring the coin into the shop and buy the merchandise.
Remember the saying, “Don’t take any wooden nickels?” If you are a wooden money collector, you want to find the wooden nickels and other wooden denominations. Wooden nickels found popularity in the 1930s as a currency replacement to offer money off for purchases or as advertisement. Wooden nickels are still being produced today mostly as an advertising mechanism.
We cannot end the discussion of exonumia without mentioning Love Tokens and Hobo Nickels. Love Tokens became popular in the late 19th century when someone, usually a man, would carve one side of a coin, turn it into a charm for a bracelet or necklace, and give it to his loved one. The designed are as varied as the artists who created them. Hobo Nickels are similar in that hobo artists would carve a design into a Buffalo Nickel to sell them as souvenirs. While there are contemporary Love Tokens and Hobo Nickels, collectors have an affection for the classic design that shows the emotion of the period.
Currency collecting, formally called notaphily, is the study and collection of banknotes or legally authorized paper money. Notes can be collected by topic, date or time period, country, paper type, serial number, and even replacement or Star Notes (specific to the United States). Some consider collecting checks part of notaphily. Collectors of older cancelled checks are usually interested in collecting them based on the issuing bank, time period, and the signature. For the history of currency and their collecting possibilities, see my previous article, “History of Currency and Collecting”.
Scripophily is the study and collection of stock and bond certificates. This is an interesting subset of numismatics because of the wide variety of items to collect. You can collect in the category of common stock, preferred stock, warrants, cumulative preferred stocks, bonds, zero-coupon bonds, and long term bonds. Scripophily can be collected by industry (telecom, automobile, aviation, etc.); autographs of the officers; or the type of vignettes that appear on the bonds.
Militaria: Honorable Collectibles
Collecting of military-related items may be considered part of exonumia but deserves its own mention. It is popular to collect military medals and awards given to members since the medals themselves are works of art. Families will save medals awarded to relatives and even create museum-like displays to honor or memorialize the loved one.
Militaria includes numismatic-related items that represent the various services. One of the growing areas of collectibles is Challenge Coins. A challenge coin is a small medal, usually no larger than 2-inches in diameter, with the insignia or emblem of the organization. Two-sided challenge coins may have the emblem of the service on the front and the back has the emblem of the division or other representative service. Challenge coins are traditionally given by a commander in recognition of special achievement or can be exchange as recognition for visiting an organization.
Over the last few years, civilian government agencies and non-government organizations (NGO) have started to create and issue challenge coins. Most of those agencies have ties to the military, but not all. Like their military counterparts, a manager or director can give challenge coins in recognition of special achievement or for visiting an organization.
Another area of military collectibles is Military Payment Certificates (MPC). MPC was a form of currency that was used to pay military personnel in foreign countries. MPC were first issued to troops in Europe after World War II in 1946 to provide a stable currency to help with commerce. MPC evolve from Allied Military Currency (AMC) to control the amounts of U.S. dollars circulating in the war zone and to prevent enemy forces from capturing dollars for their own gain. Prior to World War II, troops were paid in the currency of the country where they were based. With the ever moving fronts and the allies need to control the economies to defeat the Axis powers, AMC was issued to allow the military to control their value.
After the war, MPC replaced APC in order to control the currency and prevent the locals from hoarding U.S. dollars preventing the building of their own economies. When military officials discovered that too many notes were in the circulation, being hoarded, and thriving on the black market, series were demonetized and reissued to military personnel. Those holding MPC notes not in the military received nothing and were encouraged to circulate their own currency.
MPC were printed using lithography in various colors that changed for each series. From the end of World War II to the end of the Vietnam War there were 15 series printed with only 13 issued. Although the two unissued series were destroyed, some examples have been found in the collections of those involved with the MPC system. Amongst the 13 series that were issues, there are 94 recognized notes available for collectors. Most notes are very affordable and accessible to the interested collector.
May 15, 2012 | education, supplies
Over the last few weeks, I have been discussing the storage of a collection with a reader via email. After researching the advice, I thought it would be good to share it with all of my readers so that you can better preserve your collection. Storing a collection is a matter of dealing with two factors: using archival safe storage materials and the environmental factors which your collection is stored.
Archival Safety
All coins, medals, tokens, and currency are made from materials that will react with the environment. Metals will oxidize and tone, some with patterns that intrigue collectors. Paper-based materials can be made from cotton rag or linen that may not break down the same way as paper but can be damaged affecting its value. The key to storing your collection is to use product made from archival safe materials. Archival safe materials are those made without acidic materials or materials that do not turn acidic over time.
Acid free means that the pH (potential Hydrogen) measure is 7.0 or greater. A pH measure of 7.0 is neutral and greater than 7.0 is basic or alkaline. Although acidic materials will damage your collection, materials too alkaline will also cause damage. Those that produce acid free supplies with materials that is as close to being pH neutral as possible.
However, it is possible to be acid free without being archival safe. All paper contains Lignin, a bonding elements that naturally occurs in the pulp used to make paper that holds the wood fibers together. While lignin is not acidic, it gives offs acids as it deteriorates. If the lignin is not treated during manufacture, you can still have acid free paper but will become acidic as it deteriorates over time. The treatment involves dipping the paper in a solution that neutralizes the natural lignin.
Another storage item to stay away from is made from polyvinyl chloride (PVC). PVC is a very inexpensive plastic that is used as an additive to other plastics to make softer, more flexible products such as 2×2 flips used to store coins. PVC in itself is neutral but gives off a gas in reaction to the atmosphere that is acidic. The PVC gas will not only react with the coins but will deteriorate the plastic. The result will be a green or gray streaks or blob appearing on the coins. Because the PVC gas is acidic it will damage the surface of the coin. Once a coin is damage by PVC it cannot be reversed. There are ways to conserve coins that are damaged by PVC as long as the PVC contamination is on the surface. Once it mars the surface, the coin is damaged and its value diminished.
When purchasing plastic or clear storage items, hard plastics or those made of Mylar are the best choice. Capsule manufacturers use a neutral plastic that does not contain PVC while those that make 2×2 flips use Mylar. The makers of 2×2 cardboard holders also use Mylar and the cover sliders found in albums.
Some people like to buy older albums because of they are unique and have a classic look. Those albums may not be made of archival material including paper with active acid from the deteriorating lignin that was not neutralized during manufacture because this was not a concern. Also, cover sliders could be made of PVC or other plastics that are not neutral. If you are not sure whether that used album is safe, it is best to buy a new archival safe album.
Environmental Factors
You can use the most archival safe materials but they will not protect your collection from environmental factors. The general rule of thumb is to stay away from the extremes. Do not store your collecting in a place that is too hot or too cold. Try not to store your collection in a place that is too humid or too dry since both could cause your storage materials to react. In other words, the average home with a temperature of 64-78 degrees with an average humidity of 30-percent should not be a problem.
Those living in colder areas where the home header is being used longer than other areas of the country may have to compensate. Forced air heating systems tend to dry the air that could cause damage to your collection. If you use a humidifier, whether built in to your heating system or a standalone unit, you might consider investing in a hygrometer to keep the relative humidity between 30 and 40-percent.
Where you store your collection also has to be a concern. If you keep your coins in a cabinet, the gasses from the wood and even the paint or stain used to cover the wood can cause damage. While wooden cabinets are attractive and practical, you do not want to store your collection some place that could add to the environmental concerns.
Metal cabinets are a better option. Safes and safety deposit boxes in temperature controlled vaults also makes great storage options aside from being able to keep your collection secure.
One of the factors that could cause wood rot in cabinets is excess humidity. If your home or where you store your collection cannot be controlled, you should use a desiccant in the area. A desiccant is a substance able to absorb moisture in the air. Two common desiccants are silica gel, the little packets that you see in some packages, and montmorillonite clay.
Choosing which desiccant to use depends on your situation. If your storage area is not that humid, use silica gel. It well suited for lower moisture area over a longer period of time, about six months. For high humidity areas, use a clay desiccant. Although it will not last as long as silica gel (about three months), clay is more effective at removing moisture when the humidity is higher. Another option is to use a combination, especially during seasons of high humidity. You can purchase silica gel and clay desiccants at many hobby stores and stores that sell collecting supplies.
While there are other types of desiccants, they are not recommended for use around collectibles. Calcium sulfate and calcium chloride uses sulfur and chlorine, both will not react well with the metals of your coins. Activated charcoal can add carbon dust to the air, which can attach itself to your coins. Some have suggested using salt as a desiccant. Salt is made of sodium chloride that would also introduce metal damaging chlorine into the environment.
Apr 30, 2012 | BEP, currency, education
Paper currency was first developed in China in the 7th century and later adapted by the Mongol Empire before spreading to Europe and then the United States. China developed currency because of a shortage or metals. Notes printed promised the holder that it be redeemed for something of value and can be traded as specie. The Mongolian Empire learned from the Chinese and issued currency that they backed by the assets of their conquests. Since both China and Mongolia issued state guaranteed currency, the paper was trusted in commerce and helped build a steady stream of commerce between Europe and the east.
Although Europe traded eastern currency as trade was opened between the regions, currency was not a part of regular trade until the 13th century. In Europe, individual banks issued currency as a promissory note against assets held by the bank. Essentially, these were promissory or demand notes that was supposed to allow the holder to trade the note for specie on demand. Unfortunately, the practice was abused to try to raise additional capital and caused a lot of banks to fail.
The problem was not limited to private banks or loan companies. Banks owned by the nation states also tried to use currency as an investment vehicle without sufficient funds to back their values. Currency manipulation by those banks lead to man bank failures and economic depression that are woven through some of the strife through Europe.
Switzerland, France, and England were the first counties to organize and regulate the banks and regulate how they issue currency. Each country has experienced bank failures of not only the state chartered banks but the state central bank making the issued paper currency worthless.
Currency did not see a wide acceptance until it was issued in the Massachusetts Bay Colony in the 17th century. It was the first time that currency was issued in predetermined amounts. Since the colonies did not have the ability to coin money, all colonies issued its own currency by the 18th century. These notes functioned as currency but actually were bills of credit, short-term public loans to the government. For the first time, the money had no intrinsic value but was valued at the rate issued by the government of the colony in payment of debt. Every time the colonial government would need money, they would authorize the printing of a specified quantity and denomination of notes that it would use to pay creditors. The emission laws also included a tax that would used to repay the bill of credit and the promised interest.
As taxes were paid using the paper currency, the paper was retired. As the notes were removed from circulation, that was less payments the government had to make. On the maturity date, people brought their notes to authorized agents who paid off the loan. Agents then turned the notes over to the colonial government to be reimbursed and collect a commission for acting as an agent.
Sometimes, colonies could not pay back the loan. In those cases, the colonies passed another emission law to cover the debt owed from the previous emission plus further operating expenses. In this case, mature notes were traded for new notes. The colonists accepted this system since there were shortages of coins as well as there being an inability to convert the value of foreign coins into colonial shillings by farmers and other unskilled in such matters.
During the revolutionary war, the Continental Congress began to issue paper money to support the war efforts. The colonies also continued to issue paper currency. While the colonial issued notes had some value, those issued by the Continental Congress was not as sure and the notes’ value plummeted. With the saying “Not Worth a Continental” becoming popular so did the term “shinplasters” to describe the notes lining colonialist’s boots to help keep their feet warm.
Counterfeiting was rampant by the mid-18th century. In order to combat the problem, Benjamin Franklin devised the nature print, an imprint of a leaf or other natural item with its unpredictable patterns, fine lines, and complex details made it more difficult to copy.
To create a nature print, Franklin placed a leaf on a damp cloth. The cloth was placed on top of a bed of soft plaster that pressed the leaf into the plaster. Once the plaster hardened, it had a negative impression of the leaf. Molten copper was then poured over the plaster to make the printing plate. Franklin first used nature prints for the 1737 New Jersey emission. He also used different leaves for different denominations and elaborately engraved borders to further thwart the efforts of potential counterfeiters.
Franklin partnered with David Hall printing notes for New Jersey and Pennsylvania colonies. Along with his nature print, Franklin also included the phrase “Tis Death to Counterfeit.” Aside from trying to scare away potential counterfeiters, the penalty for counterfeiting in the 18th century was death. No convictions for counterfeiting colonial currency or death sentences have been recorded.
Later, Hall partnered with William Sellers to print Pennsylvania currency when the Pennsylvania assembly sent Franklin to England as their colonial agent.
Other printers tried different methods to thwart counterfeiters. James Parker of Woodbridge, New Jersey printed notes in two colors. With printing a labor-intensive process, it was thought the process to cumbersome for counterfeiters to go through the process of the second printing. Also, Parker used red ink as the second color. Red was more expensive than black ink in the 18th century.
The next wave of note is known as Obsolete Notes, sometimes called Broken Banknotes. These were privately issued currency starting in the 1830s backed by the assets of the issuing bank. These notes became obsolete in the 1860s when many of the issuing banks failed and the federal government changed the laws regarding currency issues. Obsolete notes are a popular collectible since many feature beautiful images, called vignettes, that represent local industries or patriotic themes.
As the Civil War raged, the public hoarded coins creating a shortage of circulating coinage. People started to use postage stamps for transaction requiring small change. Stamps were traded in envelopes that would fall apart causing the gum on the back to make them a sticky mess. As a result, the post office issued small, rectangular Postage Currency in 1862. Postage currency was larger than the postage stamp without the gum on the reverse, and the front depicted the postage stamp and its value. Without the adhesive, they could not be used for postage but could be redeemed at any post office for its face value.
Currency in the United States went from its chaotic stage to something the government issued and regulated with the passage of the National Bank Act of 1863. The law replaced the postage currency with fractional currency. Authorize by the government and printed by the American Banknote Company, fractional currency was issued through 1876 when coinage production caught up with demand and hoarding had ended. At this time, the Currency Bureau, later to be renamed the Bureau of Engraving and Printing (BEP) was created to cut and distribute the notes. Fractional currency is a popular collectible especially amongst those with interest in the Civil War.
Another Civil War collectible is Confederate Currency. These banknotes were primarily demand or promissory notes back by non-existent assets that made the notes worthless by the end of the war. During the war, the Confederate States of America issued seven series of currency printed by different printers throughout the south, some in the north, and in London. Confederate coinage, also collectible, was struck using mints under siege in Charlotte, Dahlonega, and New Orleans. During the Civil War, the chief coiner of the New Orleans Mint fled to France to continue producing coins for the Confederacy. This history makes these numismatics are very collectible by history and Civil War buffs.
Following the Civil War, paper currency is identified by type, denomination, and series date. The series date is not necessarily the date in which the note was issued. The series could represent the year the law authorized the notes, the year the production began, or in the case of current Federal Reserve Notes, the year when the signature of the Secretary of the Treasury changes.
Not including fractional and Confederate currency, the following are characteristics of United States currency:
- Demand Notes were the first paper currency printed for the United States government for general circulation. These notes were essentially loans to the government during the Civil War to be paid on demand at designated Treasury offices following a maturity date. The backs of these notes were printed in green to prevent counterfeiting by people taking pictures of the note using a camera, the new technology of the time. Green did not photograph well. The term “greenback” came from the use of green inks to print these notes.
- United States Notes were the first currency authorized by the Legal Tender Act of 1862 and the first notes printed by the National Currency Bureau. Also known as Legal Tender Notes, these notes were supposed to be backed by assets held by the government that were not necessarily precious metals. Large size United States Notes are very collectible with great designs that make them special.
- National Bank Notes allowed banks with a federal charter to issue notes against their assets. In order for the banks to be allowed to issue currency, they had to purchase bonds from the Treasury and were allowed to issue currency up to 90-percent of the value of those bonds. The bonds were used by the federal government to insure the value of the notes. All notes were printed by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing to ensure that the designs were identical with only the bank name, location, and charter number printed for the issuing banks. The National Bank Note program ended in 1935 when the bonds securing the notes were terminated as part of the banking reorganization during the Great Depression. National Bank Notes are great collectibles for those interested in collecting items representing a state or region.
- Silver Certificates began in 1878 when the government decided to increase the production of silver coinage with the passage of the Bland-Allison Act to satisfy silver mining interests. Silver coins were deposited with the Treasury and the equivalent dollar amount of silver certificates where produced. Silver Certificates could have been presented to the Treasury Department and redeemed for silver dollars. The series 1953B silver certificates were the last produced for circulation. In 1964, with the price of silver rising, the Treasury stopped redeeming silver certificates for silver dollars and started to distribute small vials of silver flake equal to $1. This redemption program stopped in 1968. All but the very rare 1934 Yellow Seal North Africa notes are available for collectors in nearly every denomination.
- Gold Certificates were generally used to transfer money between banks and other large financial institutions. First issued in 1878, Gold Certificates were backed with gold deposited with the Treasury. Some of the lower denominations did circulate to a limited degree, but banks used others. Gold certificates were printed with bright colors, mostly gold-colored, and the reverse on the large notes (pre-1929) were also gold-colored. Small notes were printed with the traditional green reverses. Gold certificates were recalled with the gold recall in 1933.
- Treasury Notes were issued as part of an 1890 and 1891 series to be paid to individuals selling silver bullion to the Treasury. Those paid with these notes could redeem them for the equivalent value in gold coins. The Treasury stopped this program after 10 years because of the considerable amount of labor required to carry out this program.
- Federal Reserve Notes (FRN) were first issued in 1914 by the newly formed Federal Reserve System and are still being printed and distributed today. When first issued, FRNs were printed as large size notes and were reduced to the small notes we are used to today in 1929. After 1945, the Bureau of Engraving and Printing stopped printing all denomination over $100. By 1969, those large denominations were removed from circulation. Designs of FRNs remained the same until 1995 when the BEP altered the designs to include new security features. However, the $1 FRN has not changed since it was first introduced in 1929. FRN are readily available and accessible to most collectors. Common ways of collecting is by signature pairs. Other ways of collecting FRNs is by serial number patterns (e.g., radar patterns, series, low numbers, etc.), and by Federal Reserve District represented by the note.
- Federal Reserve Bank Notes (FRBN) began to be issued in 1915 to transition from National Bank Notes to Federal Reserve notes. FRBN were obligations of the issuing Federal Reserve Bank branch and not the U.S. government. FRBN production was discontinued in 1934 and were stopped being issued in 1945. Since FRBN resembled National Bank Notes except that the issuing bank is a Federal Reserve Branch and are printed with “National Currency” across the top.
Currency collections can be as varied as the types of currency printed. Some currency was printed with themes such as the Educational Series of 1896 that used allegorical images in an attempt to educate the public. Other ways to collect currency is by their design, the color of the seal, the issuing bank, serial numbers, and signers.
If you collect by signers on the note, one of the more interesting notes is known as Barr Notes named for Joseph W. Barr, the 59th Secretary of the Treasury. Barr was confirmed and sworn into office on December 21, 1968, one month before the end of the Lyndon B. Johnson administration. Since the Secretary of the Treasury’s signature is on all Federal Reserve Notes, the BEP printed over 485 million one dollar notes with Barr’s signature before his term ended on January 20, 1969.
In the case of currency, size matters. Aside from the denomination, standard currency printed by the BEP used to be larger than it is today. Prior to 1929, U.S currency was 7 1/2 inches long by 3 1/8 inches wide. These are commonly called large notes. Another nickname for these notes are horse blankets. Beginning in 1929 with the Series 1928 notes, U.S. currency was reduced to the 6 1/8 inches by 2 5/8 inches notes we are used to using today. These are commonly called small notes.
If you ever looked at a note and noticed that a star (“*”) was included in the beginning or end of the serial number, you have a Star Note. A Star Note is used to denote that the note is a replacement note for one found to be defective or damaged during the printing process. To maintain the correct number of notes in a print run, the serial numbers are reclaimed and a star is added to note the replacement. Since Star Notes are replacements for errors, they are not as common as normal notes and are popular with collectors.
Apr 25, 2012 | coins, education
Numismatics is the collecting and study of items used in the exchange for goods, resolve debts, and objects used to represent something of monetary value. The dominant area of numismatics is the collection and study of legal tender coins with United States coins being the most collected. But there are so many other forms of numismatics that there are collectibles to pique anyone’s interest.
Evidence of coin collecting has been found as far back to the early days of the Roman Empire when collecting art came into vogue. Since coin design was considered art, it was assumed that coins were part of every collection. Archeologists have discovered hoards of coins with no two being alike in the areas believed to be cultural centers of the Roman Empire. The fact that the hoards have unique coins have archeologist beliving that these were lost collections.
Coin collecting did not become a broader hobby until the Italian Rennaisance when the lords and kings began to collect what we call ancient coins primarily found on their land or during conquests of other lands. Since only these nobles could afford to collect, coin collecting became known as the “Hobby of Kings.”
By the 17th century, collectors started to study and catalog the coins in their collection beginning the era of numismatic research that continues today. As the study of the coins began to advance, there was the rise of public collections. Coins held by the royalty were either given or confiscated for the state and placed in museums. As the collections began to build, museums began to sponsor research to document their holdings.
Modern numsimatics is said to have begun in the 19th century with the interest in the coins of a new nation. Collectors in the United States and overseas saw potential in the promise of the new coinage as the nation grew. By the latter part of the century after congress ended the use of foreign coins in commerce, collectors started to hoard older designs and created clubs for collectors to network and share information.
The 20th century saw new markets for numismatics develop. Growing interest in numismatics caused excavation of sites believed to have been inhabited in ancient times to find coins while hoards of United States gold and silver coins were being discovered primarily in Europe with others found in Asia. Collectors started searching banks and pocket chains for coins like the 1909-S VDB and 1914-D Lincoln Cents, 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickels, and 1916-D Mercury Dime.
The first change in numismatics came with the introduction of the coin board, cardboard-made boards with holes the size of the coins so that collectors can organize their collections. Coin boards introduced the concept of collecting coins in a series. Boards were printed to allow the collector to insert coins of each date and the date with mint mark. Soon after publishers printed folders that brought down the size of the coin board so it could fit on a book shelf and then the album with the ability to view both sides of the coin.
Another change occurred in 1955 when the 1955 Double-Die Obverse (DDO) Lincoln Cent was discovered. Known as the “King of Errors,” this coin lead to collectors to search for errors, varieties, and anything out of the ordinary. New clubs were formed to organize and promote this new hobby segment. One of the most comprehensive study of die varieties was published in 1971 by Leroy C. Van Allen and A. George Mallis. Their book, The Comprehensive Catalog and Encyclopedia of Morgan & Peace Dollars, documents the dies and strike varieties of America’s last circulating large silver dollars. Their catalog, also known as the “VAM Book” provides a numbering system to identified the different varieties whose impact created a new way to collect silver dollars.
The biggest change in coin collecting occurred in 1965 when the United States stopped striking coins using silver. With the price of silver rising and costing more than their face value, the country was facing a coinage shortage as people started to hoard the coins vor their silver values. Although the government erroneously blamed collectors, congress voted to change the composition of what were silver coins to copper-nickel clad alloy. Even though the half-dollar continued to be minted in silver until 1970, the silver was clad over a copper core.
Collectors consider 1964 the end of the United States’s classic coin era and 1965 the beginning of the modern era. The modern era saw the last of the large dollars and the transition to the small dollars, changes in composition for the Lincoln cent, the rotating circulating commemorative series beginning with tht 50 State Quarters program, and the reintroduction of the commemorative coin program. Another addition to the modern era in the United States and around the world is the resurgance of bullion coins.
After the world stopped using precious metals for coins, South Africa made a strategic decision to continue to strike the 22-karat krugerrand for world investment. For many years, the krugerrand was the standard for bullion investment until the United States began the American Eagle Bullion Program striking silver and gold coins. While other countries have followed suit, the American Eagle set the standard that other countries followed. Also popular at the Chinese Pandas, Canadian Maple Leafs, British Britannias, Mexican Libertads, and Australia Kookaburra.
Bullion programs lead to a new set of collectibles that are a cross between bullion and commemoratives called non-circulating legal tender (NCLT) coins. NCLT collecting has introduced new collecting opportunities by allowing mints and central banks to create new themes to intice new collectors and established collectors to expand their collections with new coins.
Rotating circulating commemorative designs and NCLT coins along with an expanded interest in other numismatic collectibles from the past including obsolete tokens, medals, old stock certificates, and paper money gives the numismatic collector an opportunity to create great collectings by collecting what you like.
Apr 13, 2012 | BEP, education, history, US Mint, video
Originally released on March 30, 2012 and updated on April 12, the Department of the Treasury updated their video honoring the history of women working for the U.S. Mint and the Bureau of Engraving and Printing over its history. The video also honors the 220th Anniversary of the U.S. Mint and the 150th Anniversary of the BEP.
Introduced by Treasurer of the United States Rosie Rios, the video shows how both the U.S. Mint and the BEP have a history of providing opportunities for women since each agencies founding.
Considering that women were considered second class citizens in the 18th century, it is amazing to find out that within two years the U.S. Mint hired two women to be adjusters. When the BEP was founded in 1862, women were hired alongside men and held the majority of positions within four years. I do not think any other agency in the U.S. government has a similar recrod.
Mar 4, 2012 | coins, education
Coin collectors love a good story, even if it is not true. New research substantiates some myths and refutes others. Many myths and popular stories include some elements of the truth or historical events. Some are simple historical events, others concoctions to make the inventor seem more important, or to pump up the value of a coin or collection.
This essay will relate a few well known numismatic myths stories and then tell you what really happened. The reality comes from new research in the national archives, museum collections, university archives, Library of Congress and the personal papers of many of the participants. Whether you prefer the “myth” or the “reality,” it is hoped that you will find them both a good story.
Peace Dollar High Relief Story
According to numismatic researcher Walter Breen, writing in his Encyclopedia of U.S. and Colonial Coins, the 1921 high relief design was too high to strike properly. So mint engraver George Morgan took a board and whacked the galvano until it was flatter and lower in relief. Morgan then cut new hubs for the 1922 and subsequent issues. Did this really happen?
Research shows that there was no flattening of the galvano as claimed by Breen because there never was a galvano. Designer Anthony de Francisci supplied his own bronze casts. Two other intermediate relief versions were made in January, 1922. Both were failures. Finally, de Francisci made new, low-relief models for 1922 and trial strikes were made and approved on February 14, 1922.
Peace Dollar Replacement Reverse Story
Another popular story says that in December 1921, just before the first coins were to be struck, Congress objected to a broken sword shown on the reverse. Since there was no time for the designer, Anthony de Francisci, to make new models, Mint engraver George Morgan quickly created a new reverse and used it in place of the original. This saved the project from failure. Did this really happen?
The design competition called for one obverse design and two reverse design. De Francisci submitted two reverse designs to the Commission of Fine arts on December 10, 1921. One design resembled the eventual design. De Francisci modified this reverse design using suggestions from James Fraser. This included a broken sword held by the eagle. The design was approved by the Mint director, Assistant Treasury Secretary, the Secretary of the Treasury, and President Warren G. Harding. A bronze cast was made of this design and sent to the Philadelphia Mint where engraver George Morgan cut a hub in preparation for striking coins.
In announcing the new coin, a Treasury Department press release mentioned a “broken sword” was part of the design on the reverse of the new coin. This was noted by the New York Herald in a scathing editorial. Subsequently, cards, letters, telegrams, and phone calls objecting to the broken sword swamped the Mint, Treasury, congress, and White House. Fraser and CFA chairman Moore suggested that the sword be cut out of the steel hub. Mint director Baker was on his way to San Francisco, so assistant secretary Malburn and acting director O’Reilley gave instructions for Morgan to do the work.
Beginning early on December 23, Morgan, accompanied by de Francisci, began removing the sword from the hub. He also had to work on the master die to compete the removal. Morgan added an olive branch and made other changes. No public mention was made of Morgan’s work. Treasury simply told the public that the sword was in one version but not the version that was used. Morgan saved the Peace dollar from failure.
Buffalo Nickel
A persistent Buffalo tale is that in preparing the hubs and dies, engraver Charles Barber eliminated most of the field texture contrary to designer James Fraser’s wishes. Another is that Barber also made the bison on plain version without the sculptor’s approval. Fraser was very upset about the way his design had been treated. Is this true?
According to Fraser’s written comments:
I find the engraving which was necessary to make the two sides of the coin fit exactly, the reduction of the edge and the simplifying of the background under the Buffalo’s head is beautifully done, showing no difference between the surface which I put on the models and the one they have made. I am delighted with their work at the Mint.
(Fraser—January 26, 1913)
Your letter of April 22nd last [sic—April 23rd] together with enclosure reached me in due course, and it seems to me that the nickel enclosed with the “Five Cents” made clearer is good and does not at all interfere with general design.
(Fraser—April 23, 1913)
Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle
One of the most popular and attractive coins ever issued by any country. As would be expected from a coin created through the cooperation of President Teddy Roosevelt and sculptor Augustus Saints-Gaudens, there are many interesting stories about the people involved. One story goes that Mint engraver Charles Barber, who harbored an intense dislike for Saint-Gaudens, was unable to make low relief dies from Saint-Gaudens’ models in late 1907. In another story, to get the coins into normal production Barber made new models copying Saint-Gaudens’ design but introducing his own variations, including changing the date to European digits, that damaged the artistic quality of the coin.
Saint-Gaudens provided the first two plaster models. The first model was delivered in December 1906. The second was the Very High Relief model that was used to make the high relief MCMVII pieces. Henry Hering submitted a third, lower relief model with European date as agreed in May. The relief on the third model was too high to coin with the Mint’s production equipment. Using the Janvier lathe caused too much detail to be lost in the reduction making the design dull and washed out. To get the coins into production as Roosevelt wanted, Barber recut detail into the hub by hand. Result was the 1907 production coin.
Henry Hering, who was Saint-Gaudens’ principal assistant for the coin design project, says that he anticipated problems with the mint over the relief of the coins, and had reductions made of Saint-Gaudens designs in Paris. These were in several different reliefs. Although the mint eventually turned out acceptable low relief coins, the officials refused to pay Mrs. Saint-Gaudens for her late husband’s work. Henry Hering claimed in his 1947 article in the Numismatist that the quality of reductions for the reverse of the $10 coin was an issue. Hering claimed the Mint refused to pay Augusta until he proved the Mint’s reductions were inferior by comparing them with ones he had ordered from Paris.
Well, not really…
Negotiations between the mint and Saint-Gaudens’ Estate were handled by Charles Brewster, Augusta’s attorney. They finally settled on a payment of $6,000. Plus Augusta was sold one of the two Extremely High Relief (EHR) pattern pieces from the Mint collection for $20 plus postage. By November 1907, Hering was superfluous and more of a nuisance than anything else. He had no role in helping Augusta get the money the mint owed her.
Adapted from the presentation “Myths and Tall Tales” by Roger Burdette given to the Montgomery County Coin Club on March 13, 2007.
All images courtesy of The Coin Page.
Feb 25, 2012 | coins, education, US Mint, video
When I went to college for my undergraduate degree, the university’s programs did not include the ability to “minor” in a subject. Aside from the core courses, we were allowed to take eight classes in our major and four electives. Along with other requirements fill-ins I was able to take history and political science classes that would qualify as a minor today. It made taking some of those required courses tolerable.
History is what makes numismatics interesting. If you look beyond the shiny metal disks, you can follow the history of the country by studying the history of the numismatics. From the first Chain Cent through the Presidential Dollars, each coin tells the story of its time. What is even more amazing is that there are people researching further than ever before and finding new information that improves our knowledge. Others are looking at that history in different ways to better understand this history better.
When a friend sent a link to a recently discovered video about the manufacturing process at the U.S. Mint, I saw it as an opportunity to see where the U.S. Mint has come from. Ignoring the opening and closing titles from the company that posted the video which provides little relevant information, the film shows the process of manufacturing coins at the U.S. Mint in the early 20th century. Watch:
There is very little in the video to try to ascertain when the film was made. To try to date this film, let’s apply a little History Detectives-like logic. Looking at the video:
- Silent films started sometime in the late 1870s with experimental films. The first narrative film was created in 1888 and by 1894, silent movies began to be shown in public spawning the initial growth of local movie houses.
- The problem with early film was that the movies were in black and while and shown as very stark on the screens. Two methods were used to “mute” the shading. One was to shoot the movie darker using darker backgrounds and lighter foregrounds. The other was tinting. Tinting added color and contrast by using special solutions of salts or dyes replacing some of the silver particles in the developing solution. Tinting was first used in 1898 but was not used on a regular basis until the early 1910s.
- Intertitles, the full screen words drawn on paper and intermixed between scenes in the folk to help narrate the story, began in 1899 but were in common use by 1901.
- The silent film era began to fade quickly after the release of the first “talkie,” The Jazz Singer, in 1927.
Based on this, we can assume that this was filmed between 1910 and 1927. But what does the film show? A lot of manual processes but the use of electricity to drive the machinery. This does not help narrow the dating except there was a large mintage of silver coins being shown. At the beginning there were also large stores of gold and silver and it film showed how the metals were smelted, formed into bars, and rolled flat to make the planchets.
At around the 36-second mark, the intertitle says “Another tidy fortune—$60,000 worth of silver bars ready to be converted into dollars, half dollars, and church collection.” (emphasis added) Converting silver into dollars stopped in 1904 and did not start again until 1921. The scenes makes the U.S. Mint look very busy and the striking of silver dollars to back silver certificates were necessary following World War I. Remember, the Pittman Act was passed in 1918 to allow the the melting of no more than 350 million silver dollars into bullion where a total of 259,121,554 ounces were sold to Great Britain at $1 per ounce to help them pay for the war. When the silver was replaced by mining and being paid back by Great Britain, it became important to replace the melted coinage for backing of silver certificates.
Providing the maker of the film did not take a little editorial liberties, that shifts the date of the film in the era of 1921-1927.
At 3:59 an intertitle is shown that reads “A forty-ton friction drive press stamps the die which later stamps the coin.” Then at 4:07, we are show the top of the friction drive press that pans down to a Mint worker positioning the dies in the press. But the press does identify itself. Arching across the top it reads “TAYLOR & CHALLEN LTD ENGINEERS BIRMINGHAM 1907.” Then below on the house for the large screw it says “PRESS 724.”
Taylor & Challen Ltd. Engineers were based in Birmingham, England. Founded in 1850 by Joseph Taylor, the company quickly rose as a leading maker of coining equipment. Their popularity came from being able to improve on the knuckle-joint action to efficiently strike and eject coins quickly from the press. According to one reference, the Model 724 was used in what we today call “hubbing,” the creating of the die by pressing the master hub into the die. What made the Model 724 well suited for this task was that the way Taylor & Challen was able to make construct the friction drive to provide the 40 tons of steady force at a slower speed than other presses to raise the clearest images on the dies with a single pressing. The U.S. Mint installed their first Model 724 in 1911 and was in use until 1933.
Just as Taylor & Challen out engineered their competition, they were out engineered by the Schuler company of Germany. Schuler invented the mechanisms to strike coins vertically so that gravity was used to speed up the striking process. Schuler remain the most popular presses around the world, including at the U.S. Mint. Taylor & Challen was never able to catch up and eventually went out of business in 1970.
As interesting as learning about Taylor & Challen was, it did not help narrow the date.
Unless I missed something, the only other observation was that most of the coins being shown in various forms were quarters. The bag tipping over at the end held a lot of quarters—Standing Liberty Quarters to be exact. So let’s say that this film was not taken in 1921 because the U.S. Mint was busy striking silver dollars. Since no quarters were struck in 1922, I can assert that the film was made between 1923-1927. I think that is as far as I can go with the evidence I can see.
If you have additional information or see evidence that I did not catch, please leave a comment to this post.
Image of the former Taylor & Challen building courtesy of Roger Marks on Flickr